Pennsylvania Supreme Court Decision Will Leave Juvenile Lifers in Prison
In 2012, the United States Supreme Court ruled that mandatory life sentences without parole for juvenile offenders were cruel and unusual punishment, sparking a glimmer of hope in hundreds of inmates across Pennsylvania. In 2013, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court dashed that hope for a time by ruling that the decision did not apply retroactively. That ruling did not last. In 2016, the U.S. Supreme Court held that the decision does apply retroactively, and most of Pennsylvania’s juvenile lifers were later resentenced.
Out of Appeals and Out of Luck
In 2012, the case of Miller v. Alabama led to a decision by the U.S. Supreme Court that mandatory life sentences without the possibility of parole for juveniles constituted cruel and unusual punishment, in violation of the Eighth Amendment. The landmark ruling came as good news for the more than 500 juvenile lifers across the state of Pennsylvania, many incarcerated for crimes committed years or even decades ago. But that flash of excitement quickly faded in 2013, when the Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled in Commonwealth v. Cunningham that Miller v. Alabama could not be applied retroactively to lifers who were already in the system and out of appeals.
Depending on the timing of their crime, some offenders found themselves holding a worse hand of legal cards than others, which left many attorneys frustrated. Marsha Levick, a Philadelphia attorney for the Juvenile Law Center, was among them. “When the U.S. Supreme Court puts down a marker,” said Levick, “it is morally unconscionable to leave any juvenile on the other side of that marker.”
Under the 2013 ruling, inmates who were sentenced more recently could still rely on Miller in their remaining appeals, while those who had exhausted their appeals before the Miller ruling stayed in prison without parole, even though the crimes themselves may have been highly similar. Bradley Bridge, an attorney with the Defender Association of Philadelphia, called the ruling “exceedingly unfair,” and Robert Buttner, another attorney, posed the question, “Are we saying children’s immaturity and development is less now than it was in the 1980s and 1990s?”
That question was answered in January 2016, when the U.S. Supreme Court decided Montgomery v. Louisiana and held that Miller applies retroactively. Every Pennsylvania juvenile lifer could then seek resentencing in the county where he or she was sentenced. In 2017, in Commonwealth v. Batts, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court set rules for those resentencings, including a presumption against life without parole that the Commonwealth could overcome only by proving beyond a reasonable doubt that the offender could not be rehabilitated. After the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2021 decision in Jones v. Mississippi, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court held in Commonwealth v. Felder (2022) that those extra Batts procedures are no longer required, but a judge must still consider the offender’s youth before imposing a life sentence. By 2022, 459 of the 521 juvenile lifers who were in Pennsylvania prisons when Montgomery was decided had been resentenced, and many have since been released on parole.
Grieving Families Welcome the Decision
However, on the other side of the fence, many victims’ families were heartened by the Pennsylvania Court’s 2013 decision. In 2003 in Allentown, PA, Darryl Romig’s 12-year-old daughter was raped and then strangled to death by Brian A. Bahr. Bahr was incarcerated at 17. Ten years later, at 27 years old, Bahr was one of the hundreds of inmates affected by these rulings. But while Bahr’s crimes were in the past, Romig’s pain was still very much present.
“It’s really good to hear,” said Romig at the time. “Really. I’m just glad he doesn’t have the chance to be resentenced. He did what he did and he deserved what he got.” Richard Long, then the executive director of the PA District Attorney’s Association, agreed with Romig. “The survivors of murder victims have had to deal with the loss of a loved one taken from them by a juvenile murderer,” said Long. “Would it be fair to have those cases reopened for another sentencing?” After Montgomery, those cases, including Bahr’s, were reopened for resentencing.
If your child is facing criminal allegations, contact the Allentown juvenile defense lawyers at Young, Marr, Mallis & Associates immediately, or call us at 215-639-5297.
