Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
Young, Marr, Mallis & Associates - Pennsylvania Bankruptcy & Criminal Defense Lawyers
Schedule A Complimentary Consultation 215-639-5297 Call or Text!
Pennsylvania Bankruptcy & Criminal Defense / Blog / General / Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition (ARD) and the Chichkin Case

Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition (ARD) and the Chichkin Case

Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition in Pennsylvania (hereafter referred to as ARD) is a Pennsylvania Statute that is encoded at Title 75 Section 1552. ARD is a minimally reporting probation, that varies from county to county in terms of the requirements, that can be used to resolve first-time offender cases that are either “driving under the influence” (DUI) or non-DUI offenses. It is often used for offenses such as Retail Theft, Drug Possession, and Criminal Mischief. It is seldom used for assaultive crimes such as Simple Assault, however in some counties that is an option. However, the focus here is the current status of ARD as it pertains to resolving DUI offenses. Our Philadelphia DUI defense lawyers discuss.

What is the ARD Statute in Pennsylvania?

The statute listed above, is addressed in the DUI section of Title 75, Pa.C.S. Sec. 3802 et al, and for years the DUI law specifically provided that resolution of the offense of DUI by way of the ARD program counted as a prior offense for purposes of the future grading of subsequent DUI charges within the next ten (10) years. In other words, ARD was basically considered “a conviction” under the prior offense section of the DUI law, 75 Pa.C.S. Sec. 3806, which sets a 10-year lookback period for DUI grading and sentencing. Thus, if after an ARD disposition, an arrest for a new DUI occurred within 10 years, the subsequent arrest was counted as a “SECOND OFFENSE” with substantially higher fines, jail time, and license suspension required. A Norristown DUI defense lawyer can elaborate.

Updates to the Pennsylvania ARD Program

The law in this area has changed several times since 2020, which has changed the way district attorney’s offices handle first offenders charged with DUI in Bucks County and throughout the state. In May of 2020, the Superior Court of Pennsylvania decided that treating ARD as essentially a “conviction” for grading future offenses within 10 years was unconstitutional. See Commonwealth v. Chichkin, 232 A.3d 959 (Pa.Super 2020). In 2022, the full Superior Court reversed course and overruled Chichkin in Commonwealth v. Richards and Commonwealth v. Moroz, allowing prior ARD to count again. Then, on May 30, 2025, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court decided Commonwealth v. Shifflett. The Court held that using a prior acceptance of ARD as a prior offense to increase a DUI sentence, without that fact being proven to a jury beyond a reasonable doubt, violates the Sixth Amendment, and it struck the ARD language from 75 Pa.C.S. Sec. 3806(a). The practical stakes are significant. If you were charged with a marijuana or drug DUI, or the highest tier alcohol DUI, as a second offense, you were looking at a mandatory minimum 90 days in jail, with supervision for up to 5 years. It would be a Misdemeanor of the first degree, which cannot be automatically sealed under Pennsylvania’s Clean Slate law, and you would have an 18-month license suspension and a fine of at least $1,500.00. As a first offense, that same case carries a mandatory 72 hours (3 days) in jail, a maximum of 6 months, a 12-month license suspension, and a fine of at least $1,000.00. A first offender may also be eligible for an ignition interlock limited license or an occupational limited license.

The Chichkin decision prompted district attorney’s offices to set their own policies on how they would first, treat new cases under the ARD program, and second, treat DUIs that fell back to a “first offense” for purposes of sentencing. For example, in Bucks County, the policy at the time was that although the offense was legally a “first offense” which meant that the maximum sentence could not exceed 6 months, prosecutors asked Defendants to serve half of what they would have served under the second offense category. In practical terms, a 90 day highest tier second offense would only carry a 72-hour mandatory minimum, but they were requiring a term of 45 days of incarceration, and generally did not object to house arrest for county residents. Defendants who did not follow the District Attorney’s “suggestion” and pleaded guilty often risked receiving even more time from the judge.

Other counties simply treated the new DUI as a first offense as if the ARD case never existed, which was obviously very favorable to the Defendant. Still others used various alternatives, and in Monroe County, for example, the ARD program stopped being used to resolve first offense DUI matters during that period. In that county, there were other options that could preserve a license, or keep a person out of jail, but those options involved a misdemeanor conviction that stays on your record for years before it can potentially be “sealed” and no longer subject to most employer review. ARD is advantageous, because not only does it prevent jail time and substantial loss of license, it also means you will have your charges dismissed upon successful completion, and in some counties automatically expunged.

ARD Lookback Period and the Chichkin Case in Pennsylvania

Another point to consider is that after the “Chichkin case”, and the Commonwealth’s frustration that ARDs could no longer be counted as a first offense in the 10 year lookback period, some District Attorney’s offices prepared forms that Defendants were required to sign in order to be enrolled in the ARD program. Lehigh County, for example, required those who wished to be placed on the ARD program for a first offense DUI to sign a form entitled, “ARD stipulation of facts” in which a Defendant agreed that the ARD could be used against him or her if they received a subsequent DUI within the next 10 years. As many Pennsylvania DUI defense attorneys expected, the legislature eventually responded. After the Shifflett decision, Act 58 of 2025, signed on December 22, 2025 and effective immediately, created a new offense called DUI following diversion, 75 Pa.C.S. Sec. 3802(h). A person who drives under the influence within 10 years after completing ARD for a DUI can now be charged under that section, and a first conviction for it is graded and penalized the same way as a second offense DUI. Because the prior ARD is now part of the offense itself, the prosecution has to prove it. The law also requires clerks of court to keep ARD completion records for DUI cases for 12 years so they are available for these prosecutions.

If You Were Charged, Contact Our Pennsylvania First Offense DUI Defense Lawyers Today

How a prior ARD affects a new DUI now depends on when the new offense happened and when the ARD was completed, so it is important to get advice before you resolve a pending case. The Delaware County DUI defense attorneys at Young, Marr, Mallis & Associates are well informed of the current laws and practices throughout the Pennsylvania suburban counties, surrounding and including Philadelphia, and would love to discuss your current or prior case and how these decisions and the new law affect your future!

Our Office Locations
Pennsylvania
Bensalem, PA
3554 Hulmeville Ave., Suite 102
Bensalem PA 19020
215-639-5297
Philadelphia, PA
7909 Bustletown Ave., 1st Floor
Philadelphia, PA 19152
215-607-7478
Bala Cynwyd, PA
2 Bala Plaza, Suite 300
Bala Cynwyd, PA 19004
610-557-3209
Easton, PA
101 Larry Holmes Dr. #212
Easton, PA 18042
215-515-7077
Quakertown, PA
328 Broad St.
Quakertown, PA 18951
215-515-6876
Allentown, PA
137 N 5th St. Suite A
Allentown, PA 18102
215-240-4082
Jenkintown, PA
135 Old York Road
Jenkintown, PA 19046
215-544-3347
Plymouth Meeting, PA
600 W. Germantown Pike #400
Plymouth Meeting, PA 19462
215-515-6876
Harrisburg, PA
2225 Sycamore St.
Harrisburg, PA 17111
717-864-8887
New Jersey
Cinnaminson, NJ
909 Route 130 South #202
Cinnaminson, NJ 08077
609-796-4344
Piscataway, NJ
200 Centennial Ave., Suite 200
Piscataway, NJ 08854
908-367-7256
Hamilton TWP., NJ
3525 Quakerbridge Rd. #903
Hamilton Township, NJ 08619
609-236-8649
Marlton, NJ
10000 Lincoln Drive E, Suite 201
Marlton, NJ 08053
856-213-2805